How to Balance Fraud Detection and Customer Experience: Actionable Strategies for Marketplaces

Marketplaces have long faced the challenge of balancing robust fraud detection with a smooth customer experience. As fraudsters grow more sophisticated, marketplaces must be vigilant – but overly aggressive fraud prevention can turn legitimate customers away.

This isn’t a new issue, but it’s one that demands constant refinement. The good news? There are actionable steps you can take right now to improve fraud detection without compromising customer experience. Whether you’re working with limited resources or implementing advanced systems, these strategies can help you strike the right balance.

1. Audit Your False Positive Rate Regularly

False positives – when legitimate transactions are flagged as fraudulent – are one of the biggest barriers to a frictionless customer experience. Even the best fraud detection systems can get this wrong, but you can minimize the impact by keeping a close eye on your false positive rate. Here’s how:

• Measure Your False Positive Rate: How often are legitimate customers being flagged? Set up a system to monitor this regularly and dig into what’s causing the alerts. If your rate is high, it's a signal that your current system is being too aggressive. You can spot-check or review a percentage of flagged accounts to identify any patterns that can help you determine more appropriate criteria.
• Adjust Your Fraud Rules: Many fraud detection systems rely on rule-based logic that can be adjusted, and it’s possible the initial rules were either adopted right out-of-the-box or enacted arbitrarily. Work with your fraud or risk teams to tweak the thresholds. (For example, loosen restrictions on high-volume or high-frequency buyers after they've made several successful transactions.) This alignment and agreement is also helpful in nurturing collaboration.

By fine-tuning your detection rules, you’ll improve the customer experience and reduce manual reviews.

2. Incorporate More Behavioral Data

One of the reasons fraud detection systems fail to identify legitimate customers is that they don’t have enough behavioral context. Many systems rely on static data like transaction history or IP addresses, but adding more behavioral insights can improve decision-making:

• Identify Data Gaps: What behavioral signals are you currently missing? Consider adding data on how customers typically interact with your platform – time spent on pages, device usage patterns, or typical browsing behaviors. Most systems will give you some degree of these metrics, and more sophisticated solutions will stitch together entire customer journeys so you get the full story. The more data you can bring into your investigations, the more you can protect your marketplace from bad actors.‍
• Use Behavior-Based Alerts: Instead of relying solely on transactional flags, set up alerts based on anomalies in behavior. For example, if a user suddenly starts purchasing more (or more expensive) items than usual, this could signal a hijacked account. Or, if a user is suddenly attempting a high number of payments in a short period of time, this could signal card testing.

These additional layers of data can help distinguish between legitimate customers and fraudulent behavior, minimizing disruption for good users.

3. Create Customer Segments Based on Risk Profiles

Not all customers are equally risky, and treating every transaction the same can lead to unnecessary friction. Segmenting customers based on their risk profiles allows you to apply the right level of scrutiny where it’s needed, without inconveniencing your trusted users. Try this:

• Segment by History: Consider grouping customers by purchase history, fraud incidence, and geographic region. It’s helpful to have access to as much user journey data as possible to ensure accurate segmentation, which will lead to more accurate decision-making. High-risk segments can undergo more intensive fraud checks and can be added to IP or suspicious address block lists if their history warrants it, while trusted buyers and sellers continue to enjoy a streamlined experience.
• Build Trust Scores: Assign a "trust score" to each customer based on their historical behavior. This is not unlike our aforementioned fraud rates, which is made better through collaboration across fraud and risk teams. Low-risk customers can have fewer verification steps – and thus a better user experience – while higher-risk customers might be prompted for additional verification, without either side being the wiser.

This approach allows you to balance protection and convenience by customizing the experience for different types of users.

4. Leverage Feedback from Manual Reviews

Manual reviews are often seen as a last resort, but they offer invaluable insights into how your fraud detection system is performing. You can use feedback from your review team to refine and improve your fraud rules and algorithms:

• Analyze Review Data: Look for patterns in manual review outcomes. Are certain types of transactions frequently flagged but ultimately approved? Is your approval workflow documented and available so every stakeholder understands criteria? Once you’ve identified trends, use this data to adjust your automated systems to better reflect real-world scenarios.
• Incorporate Fraud Analyst Feedback: Fraud analysts can often spot nuances that automated systems miss. (They’re experts for a reason.) Make sure their insights are fed back into your fraud prevention strategies so that the highest number of legitimate customers receive a friction-free experience.

This iterative process will help you continuously improve fraud detection accuracy and reduce the need for future manual reviews.

5. Prioritize Transparency and Communication with Customers

When legitimate customers are caught in your fraud detection net, frustration can quickly lead to abandonment. Clear communication is essential to minimize friction when extra verification steps are necessary. A couple of ways to do that:

• Explain the Why: If a customer is flagged for verification, provide a simple explanation for why this is happening. For example, “For your security, we need to verify this transaction due to unusual activity.” This simple statement of explanation can aid in retaining business, building trust, and saving the overall experience – not to mention, prevent fraudulent activity from prevailing.
• Offer Easy Resolutions: Make it as easy as possible for legitimate customers to resolve issues. If they’re having trouble logging in or making payments, try offering multiple verification options, like SMS or email verification, and aim for quick resolution times. Set a SLA with your teams, if necessary.

Empathetic and customer-centric fraud prevention helps preserve trust, even when extra security measures are needed.

===

Constant Refinement is Key to Success

The challenge of balancing fraud detection with customer experience isn’t new, and it’s not going away. But with the right strategies in place, you can refine your approach, reduce false positives, and provide a seamless experience for your customers.

Remember, fraud prevention is not a one-size-fits-all solution. By continuously auditing your processes, incorporating new data, and refining your rules, you can stay ahead of both fraudsters and customer expectations.

Taking small, actionable steps today can lead to big improvements in how you protect your marketplace—while keeping your customers happy.

Have a specific fraud challenge in mind?
Explore more resources on optimizing fraud prevention at scale.